Photoshop Contest PhotoshopContest.com
Creative Contests. Real Prizes. Essential Resource.
You are not logged in. Log in or Register

 
Photoshop Contest Head to Head Tournament 2010
seelcraft vs Sh!Za
winner! votes round compare to
seelcraft 81 Round #1 original
Winning Image

Voting Details
VoterComment
:-@dolly :-@dolly
...
TheShaman TheShaman
both are nice repairs. going with the motion though
DLowrie DLowrie
...
nyxxie nyxxie
I luv the action to this. But I have to say that I luv the story of how it got broke with both entries.
Tesore Tesore
Good couple! ;-)
janetdog janetdog
close battle
Tawiskaro Tawiskaro
Lot's of reconstruction work in both, but I have to go with the action shot. The hammer in the second entry is a bit weak.
spencej1129 spencej1129
...
Meeshoo Klan Meeshoo Klan
...
TofuTheGreat TofuTheGreat
Gotta vote this clean up as it tells the story better.
Mel47 Mel47
...
dannyboyuk09 dannyboyuk09
I like this one because of the "Whats about to happen" aspect of it...
Starman Starman
...
dewking dewking
Great job! Love that its not just a simple "fix", but also tells a story of the "seconds before".
ReyRey ReyRey
Flips coin..... You win
annajon annajon
I like this idea, not the shadow though
max&roro max&roro
...
kittie kittie
Voting for this for a better idea in my opinion... I like the motion that you put into it....
Sliver Sliver
...
blue_lurker blue_lurker
Nice work on both, I like the effect on this one.
TJ TJ
...
woobie woobie
...
UntExp UntExp
...
buglover buglover
secs before. right?
pakimo pakimo
Nice movement and good rebuild :)
Sjitske Sjitske
...
Trann Trann
...
rockfisch rockfisch
...
Alex Alex
...
Tommeken Tommeken
both very good entry's but this one is the one i like the most..the coffe should be a bit darker ;) nice work anyway
Huubbbb Huubbbb
...
Sanctuary Sanctuary
yeah!!
vokaris vokaris
Tough choice. This one has a better composition, but the other has better shadows and cleanup.
Mid Mid
...
TheLeftHand37 TheLeftHand37
both excellent. love theidea!
nevet nevet
...
vunt van pumununt vunt van pumununt
...
NButler NButler
...
Krank Krank
...
metalic metalic
...
Eve Eve
:)
JORDAN792 JORDAN792
this should be a close one... This one wins for me because of the shadows... because both of them are good, the other is just lacking some good shadows
gramps gramps
...
YerPalAl YerPalAl
I imagine we'll see a lot of cups repaired, but this one is cleverly done.
anfa anfa
Cool movement!
Azionite Azionite
This is hard to decide.. like this one just a bit more..
Janfet Janfet
2 seconds before the crash... Good job!
badcop badcop
...
Salvezza Salvezza
Very hard to decide on these...lol..both were so good!
marcoballistic marcoballistic
this was bloody tight, I went back and forth, what made it was the hammer was not needed in the other and bad shadow work, although this is not the best, but I like the action, both good repairs, just, and I mean just, this one
supak0ma supak0ma
at least you added a story, step it up if you pass
DaVinci DaVinci
...
nifft nifft
...
Lord David Lord David
...
Netwel Netwel
nice
Chopper Chopper
...
Granulated Granulated
both good. the rather poor hammer integration on the other one swings it
Michel Michel
Can't decide on the one I like!
BroChris BroChris
love it
MamaBallistic MamaBallistic
I like the movement in this entry however I'm not too sure about the shadow from the liquid. The other entry is good too but I'm afraid a still repair vs this just isn't enough for me.
screwloose screwloose
Tuff choice, but I'm like'n the motion in this one
clonestamp trooper clonestamp trooper
glennhanna glennhanna
I'm digging the action.
Pearcinator Pearcinator
The better cleanup of the two. At least this cleanup has something happening! The other entry is quite good but I dont get the hammer (same hammer I used in my chop lol)
bneises bneises
...
Dechene Dechene
the coffee looks more like a dog tongue waggling out but i like the motion of it. the other has a very well put together cup, but the hammer looks a bit off perspective to me.
abraham abraham
...
Goat1981 Goat1981
...
KENNY CHUNG KENNY CHUNG
...
EJH EJH
...
jefflang007 jefflang007
...
L@rue L@rue
...
pollyO pollyO
...
Eepi Eepi
...
Chris. Chris.
...
Doc_isme Doc_isme
...
bsoholic bsoholic
...
m0nk m0nk
...
Carcarlo Carcarlo
...
soulrock soulrock
...
carmine665 carmine665
...


author votes round compare to
Sh!Za 62 Round #1 original

Voting Details
VoterComment
kinetic_be kinetic_be
billtvshow billtvshow
Barely.
Napalm32 Napalm32
rose-wood71 rose-wood71
like the idea
volkswes volkswes
good cleanup
bogsy bogsy
claudiolky claudiolky
Cartoon Contractor Cartoon Contractor
Both good! I liked this one a little better!
Heinlein Heinlein
spikelmalo spikelmalo
better hammerless
Hagen Hagen
Should work a little bit on the shadows of both the hammer and the cup...! But good reconstruction of the cup...!
mawaho mawaho
Well constructed
Watch them Drift Watch them Drift
I had that same hammer but due to perspective problems it was removed. I like the lip on the cup, something I should have done to mine.
Prince Laurent Prince Laurent
not sure about some shadows, but my fav. (clean job)
Mir Mir
good work on the mug
Dead Man Dead Man
seelcraft seelcraft
Good work! I know how hard it was to repair the cup, and repairing the tiles was even harder!
mikey mikey
ihaveissues ihaveissues
MonkeeDrummer MonkeeDrummer
I think they're both a little cliche, but I'll vote for this one, It's super simple and clean which is nice. As for the other, I like the falling mug idea, but the actual "coffee" just didn't do it for me.
jazgraphic jazgraphic
bigbuck bigbuck
rruotolo rruotolo
kbuzz818 kbuzz818
great work fixing the cup, also i like the hammer haha
cafn8d cafn8d
I always get a kick when both opponents do the same theme. "Good job" to both!
JAM JAM
deshone deshone
best of the two ...
Tad Tad
neurotoxic neurotoxic
Better done
mastermason mastermason
CarlC CarlC
ReinMan ReinMan
both similar ideas, but the coffee looks more real in this one (just a bit more real - the spill on the other one just doesn't seem right to me... but then I've drank too much coffee this morning so what the hell do i know. Okay - I'll just vote now....
pjsev pjsev
;)
Patre Patre
dbbowling dbbowling
thbeghin thbeghin
;)
Huni Huni
delia delia
rett435 rett435
Jake420 Jake420
nice rebuild on the cup didn't need the hammer
the burning couch the burning couch
sirenka sirenka
koorio koorio
Hmm..
rashdog rashdog
rockyjob rockyjob
nancers nancers
Interesting that you both had the same "put it back together" idea.
jorzza jorzza
lol, google images hammer, just like pearcinator. Nice work on the cup
nat_g31 nat_g31
Hard decision. The cleaned up cup is just too easy of an idea. I vote for this because the splashing liquid and motion blur could have been done a bit better.
Tea Man Tea Man
Oscar Oscar
The hammer doesn't quite fit but this is a great chop overall.
Synthvet Synthvet
anabe anabe
good
jazpur jazpur
sonic3 sonic3
Stevster Stevster
Better execution, but still a hard choice.
charliesou charliesou
ElectronChaser ElectronChaser
TutorMe TutorMe
Both nice entries. This one is better executed. Shadows are a bit strong imo.
Cambria Cambria
j58roldan j58roldan
Claf Claf
This one. Nice!
mellowdesign mellowdesign


« Go to previous match - back to tournament - Go to next match »
Navigate PSC
Contests active  archives  winners  prizes  sponsors  events  rules  rss 
Galleries votes  authentic  skillful  funny  creative  theme  winners 
Interact register  log in/out  forum  chat  user lookup  contact 
Stats monthly leaders  hall of fame  record holders 
PSC advantage  news  (rss)  faq  about  links  contact  home 
Help faq  search  new users  tutorials  contact  password 

Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved.
A venture of ExpertRating.com

PSC Time 10:38 pm EST